Home / Comparisons / Collective Shift vs The Mining Store
Comparison
Collective Shift vs The Mining Store
These two Melbourne businesses offer very different ways into Bitcoin. Mining Store (often searched as The Mining Store) sells ASIC mining hardware and hosts it for you, so you own machines that earn rewards from the Bitcoin network. Collective Shift is a research and education membership: you buy and hold digital assets yourself, guided by the 5-step SHIFT Method and the Live Crypto Portfolio. If you want to own mining hardware, Mining Store is built for that. If you want to learn to invest, we are.
The Short Answer
Which Is Better, Collective Shift or Mining Store?
It depends on what you want to own. With Mining Store you own mining hardware, and your results depend on things its own guides list, such as electricity costs, the hardware, network difficulty, halvings and the Bitcoin price. With Collective Shift you own the digital assets directly in your own wallets, and what you buy is education: a written Strategy Sheet, a Profit Ladder, daily research and the Live Crypto Portfolio. Neither manages your money, and some investors do both.
Definitions
What Each One Is
Three plain questions for each: what it is, who it is for and what it does.
Mining Store
What is it? A Melbourne-based Bitcoin mining hardware and hosting business, which its Our Story page says was started by William Wright and Callum Cameron to make mining accessible to Australians.
Who is it for? Australians who want to own crypto mining hardware, either hosted in its facilities or set up at home.
What does it do? Sells ASIC miners, hosts and maintains them, runs an on-site service centre, offers free consultations and a profitability calculator, and runs a community Discord with its partner Imperial Wealth.
Collective Shift
What is it? An Australian digital asset research and education company, founded in 2020 by Ben Simpson, with a team of 15+ staff.
Who is it for? Business owners and busy professionals who already hold crypto, or are ready to, and want a written plan rather than a feed of tips.
What does it do? Two 12-month memberships built on the 5-step SHIFT Method, daily research, the Digital Asset Academy and the Live Crypto Portfolio, with analyst access throughout.
Side by Side
Collective Shift and Mining Store Compared
Everything in the Mining Store column comes from its own website as of 27 October 2026. Rows we could not source are marked.
| Compared on | Collective ShiftResearch membership, Australia | Mining StoreMining hardware and hosting, Melbourne |
|---|---|---|
| Where it is based | Australia. Founded in 2020 by Ben Simpson, with a team of 15+ staff including an internal analyst team. | Melbourne, Victoria, according to the contact details on its site. |
| What you are buying | A 12-month education and research membership. You buy and hold any digital assets yourself, in your own name. | Mining hardware (ASIC miners), with the option to have it hosted and maintained in its facilities or shipped to you. |
| What you own afterwards | Whatever digital assets you choose to buy, held in your own wallets, plus a written plan you keep. | The mining hardware, which earns rewards from the network through the mining pool you choose. |
| What drives results | The assets you choose, your entry points, and whether you follow your written rules for taking profits. | Its profitability guide lists electricity costs, network difficulty, block reward halvings, the hardware and the Bitcoin price. |
| Hands-on work | Reading research, building your plan in the first 4 weeks, then reviewing it on live calls. | Its site says hosted miners are set up for you, and you provide the mining pool you want to mine into. |
| First step | A free 30 to 45 minute strategy call to confirm which membership fits before anything is charged. | A free consultation, or buy a miner online. |
| Research and education | Daily research, individual asset research, the Digital Asset Academy and the Live Crypto Portfolio (see our analysts’ portfolio buys and sells), with the thesis and rebalancing rationale behind each move. | Free guides and news on its site, and its menu lists a crypto trading course, The Trading Academy and a DeFi trading course. |
| Community | A 4-week live program at the start of the 12-month membership covering foundations, allocation, your investor operating system and your sell strategy, then weekly live strategy calls, Ask the Analysts and a private investor community. | A community Discord shared with Imperial Wealth, with rooms for mining, trading, master nodes and news. |
| Guarantee | Every new member is covered by our 14-day money-back guarantee, with conditions set out in the policy. | Not verified here. We have not sourced this detail, so we make no claim either way. |
| Regulatory position | General information and education only. We do not provide personal financial advice, we do not place trades and we never hold your assets. | Not verified here. We have not sourced this detail, so we make no claim either way. |
We only state things about Mining Store that we can source from its own site. “Not verified here” means we have not confirmed that detail, not that Mining Store does not offer it. We have left out prices for both sides; check each provider directly. Mining Store is not affiliated with Collective Shift and has not reviewed this page.
Fit
Who Each One Suits
Conditions rather than verdicts. One of these should sound like you.
Choose Mining Store if
You specifically want to own Bitcoin mining hardware, you are comfortable with the running costs and the factors its own guides describe, and you would rather have the machines hosted and maintained for you than run them at home. That is a clear, defined product and it is what Mining Store is built around.
Choose Collective Shift if
You want to own digital assets directly rather than hardware, and you want to learn how to choose them, size them and take profits on the way up. You want a written Strategy Sheet, daily research, the Live Crypto Portfolio and analysts to check your thinking with for 12 months.
A fair note on mining and investing
Mining and investing are not opposites. Some people mine and also hold Bitcoin they bought. What matters is knowing which risks you are taking on: with mining, running costs and network changes; with investing, price swings and your own discipline. Whichever path you take, write down how much capital it gets before you start.
Inside Collective Shift
How a Collective Shift Membership Works
Members rate us 4.8 out of 5 from 135+ verified Trustpilot reviews. Here is what the first year looks like.
The first 4 weeks: the live program
Every new member starts with a 4-week live program covering foundations, allocation, your investor operating system and your sell strategy. You finish it with a written Strategy Sheet, then have the rest of the 12 months to run it with support.
The Live Crypto Portfolio
You see our analysts’ portfolio buys and sells as they happen, with the thesis and rebalancing rationale for each move, so you learn from the decisions as well as the research.
Platinum: Private Analyst Sessions
Platinum members get 8 Private Analyst Sessions a year, where an analyst works through your own portfolio with you for education, plus a dedicated client success manager and two in-person masterminds a year.
Before You Decide
Six Questions to Ask on Either Call
Ask both providers the same questions and compare the answers. These are the ones we would want answered.
- What exactly will I own at the end, and where is it held?
- Which costs keep running each month, and what happens to my results if the Bitcoin price falls?
- How do halvings and rising network difficulty affect what I earn or learn?
- Who do I talk to when something goes wrong, and how quickly?
- What are the refund or warranty terms, and where are they written down?
- Is any of this personal financial advice, or general information only?
Common Questions
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Mining Store the same as The Mining Store?
Yes. The company calls itself Mining Store, or Mining Store Australia, at miningstore.com.au, and many people search for it as The Mining Store. It is not connected to Collective Shift.
Is Bitcoin mining the same as investing in Bitcoin?
No. When you mine, you own hardware that competes to earn new Bitcoin, and your result depends on running costs, network difficulty and the price. When you invest, you buy Bitcoin or other digital assets directly. Collective Shift teaches the investing side through the 5-step SHIFT Method.
What affects mining results?
Mining Store’s own guides list electricity costs, network difficulty, block reward halvings, the hardware and the Bitcoin price. It offers a profitability calculator and free consultations to estimate this for a given machine.
Can I mine and also be a Collective Shift member?
Yes. They do different jobs. Some investors hold mining hardware as one part of their crypto exposure, and use their written Strategy Sheet to decide what happens to the Bitcoin they earn or buy.
Why should I trust a comparison you wrote yourselves?
Read it sceptically. Everything we say about Mining Store comes from its own website, linked on this page, rows we could not source are marked as not verified, and the fit section says when it is the better choice. If anything is out of date, tell us and we will correct it.
General information only. Nothing on this page takes your objectives, financial situation or needs into account, and it is not personal financial advice. Mining Store is a trademark of its respective owner and is named here for identification and comparison only.
Not Sure Whether to Mine or Invest?
Bring your questions to a free 30 to 45 minute strategy call. We will tell you honestly whether a 12-month research membership suits you, or whether owning mining hardware is closer to what you want.
Our Process
The 5-Step SHIFT Method
Every Collective Shift membership runs on the same five-step operating system. Process comes first, proof comes second, and outcomes follow from written rules rather than emotion.
S
Set your plan in writing
Before any money goes in, you write down what you own, why you own it, how much you will put in and what would make you change your mind. That written plan is your Strategy Sheet.
H
Hold Bitcoin as your core
Bitcoin sits at the centre of the portfolio, and you decide in advance how you will hold it and where it is kept.
I
Invest in on-chain businesses with real revenue
Beyond Bitcoin, the focus is on networks and applications that run on a blockchain (on-chain) and earn real fees from real users.
F
Filter every coin before you buy
Every coin goes through the same checks before you buy it, including who holds the supply, what unlocks are coming and whether anyone actually uses it.
T
Take profits on the way up
You plan partial sales in advance with a Profit Ladder, so selling happens by plan rather than by panic.
Still Comparing Options?
See every comparison we have written, or read our guide to the best crypto research platforms and how to judge them.